Talarico's Pizzeria West Seattle

K James Edited a month ago

Update: I ordered a slice of Al pastor pizza and it had a lot more meat, bread was thicker, and even came with a side of salsa. I was so full I couldn’t even finish the slice! Tasted great. Glad I gave it a second chance. I will be coming back often. Updated to 5 stars! Original review: I tried their birria pizza and while it was good, I was disappointed in the pathetic amount of meat. I’m hoping it was just a bad day for them and they ran out of meat because the concept is delicious and I do want to try it again. I’ll update with a picture next time I order another slice. Service was friendly, the restaurants atmosphere was nice and divey

Kristi F 3 months ago

Been to karaoke night a millions times here before - 11/10 recommend going! It’s also a great spot to throw a casual party. Had my daughter’s birthday party here and was able to easily hold a large group. Also shout out to the staff! Every single staff member we’ve ever interacted with has been great!

Jeremy Yowell 3 months ago

Visited Talarico's for a friend's birthday in a pretty large group and had a solid time! The space inside was large and well decorated (looks like it may have originally been a Chinese restaurant so there's still some dragon decor on the walls.) We had a pre selected set of vegetarian friendly pizzas for the party which were all tasty, although I can't say the crust on one of my slices seemed fully cooked. Toppings were nice and fresh though. The salad we had was also fresh / a nice pairing to the New York style pizza. Would go back to try more individual slices and other options on the menu.

Hoov 6 months ago

At first I was a little hesitant about the price, but it did make more sense once you see the size of the slices. They are about twice the size of a pagglicci pizza slice. Might be twice as good, but I only had a single slice of the Tarantino, so I can't yet say that for sure. It tasted great, if a Lil light on the cheese. I also got a chop chop salad which I felt was a little more expensive that id wished for the small, but it was really damn good! I loved the pepperoncinis in it. I was quite full after the salad and a single slice. I'll definitely come back to try a pepperoni, and the Sinatra looks good too. There's actually a few things I wanna try. Oh I almost forgot to mention both the servers that helped me, the guy who sat me down and the girl who served me were super nice and professional / accommodating.

Divya Rajesh 8 months ago

This place has the BEST pizza! The portion size is massive and it’s really bang for your buck. I’ve been here multiple times, but love the Al Pastor the most! The Tiramisu is also a notable mention.